| 2010 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 27 | Colorado Buffaloes (Mark Gamble) | 9 |
| 2009 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 37 | UCLA Bruins (Martyn Blackmore) | 29 |
| 2008 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 38 | Miami Hurricanes (D.Flesfader/A.Den Riet) | 31 |
| 2007 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 31 | Penn State Lions (Jay Lutwyche) | 27 |
| 2006 | Miami Hurricanes (D.Flesfader/A.Den Riet) | 47 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 34 |
| 2005 | Penn State Lions (Jay Lutwyche) | 24 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 14 |
| 2004 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 21 | Miami Hurricanes (D.Flesfader/A.Den Riet) | 17 |
| 2003 | Miami Hurricanes (D.Flesfader/A.Den Riet) | 39 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 38 |
| 2002 | Auburn Tigers (Rob Crowther) | 53 | Miami Hurricanes (D.Flesfader/A.Den Riet) | 29 |
| 2001 | Washington Huskies (Martyn Williams) | 34 | Miami Hurricanes (Dave Flesfader) | 22 |